How an Arizona pastor followed an toddler left by way of nomadic ‘cult’ after oldsters’ murders

How an Arizona pastor followed an toddler left by way of nomadic ‘cult’ after oldsters’ murders

The tale of “Child Holly” has made nationwide headlines lately, and there’s a robust Arizona connection to the girl discovered alive and neatly greater than 40 years after being separated from her murdered oldsters.

Their killings are nonetheless unsolved, and government say a cult might be connected to the crimes.

The start of Holly Clouse’s existence is a thriller, however investigators know a part of her existence came about within the wilderness.

Grisly discovery sparks investigation

Donna Casasanta is Holly’s organic grandmother.

“A nightmare. It was once one thing that was once on our thoughts continuously and I am questioning what took place to her,” Casasanta mentioned.

For greater than 40 years, she had no clue the place Holly or her oldsters might be.

“Each time the telephone rang, I feel, possibly this, that … you do not need them to be useless, thoughts you, however but you wish to have to put it to leisure, you wish to have to determine what took place,” Casasanta mentioned.

Within the overdue 70s, her son Harold Dean Clouse Jr. and his spouse Tina left Florida for Texas after having Holly. By way of October 1980, Casasanta stopped listening to from them.

Investigators in Texas say a girl who went by way of “Sister Susan” known as Casasanta, claiming she sought after to promote Dean’s automotive again to his circle of relatives. They met on the Daytona Racetrack in Florida the place 3 younger girls seemed in white gowns and sandals.

They reportedly instructed Casasanta, “Your son are not looking for any touch with you anyway, not one of the circle of relatives, they have joined a gaggle, a cult and they are with us now and he will no longer communicate to you.”

By way of January 12, 1981, seek canines made a grisly discovery in Texas.

“In 1981, two deceased people had been came upon within the wooded house in Houston, Texas. Their identities may no longer be made up our minds at the moment. What legislation enforcement did know is they had been most probably murdered,” mentioned Brent Webster, the First Assistant Lawyer Normal of Texas.

In 2021, genealogists in the end recognized the our bodies as Dean and Tina Clouse. Dean was once certain and crushed and Tina was once strangled after they died.

The Texas Lawyer Normal’s Place of work is now offering main points at the nomadic non secular crew most likely hooked up to the murders and Holly’s preliminary disappearance.

“They had been dressed in white gowns they usually had been barefoot. They indicated the ideals in their faith incorporated the separation of female and male participants, working towards vegetarian conduct and no longer the usage of or dressed in leather-based items,” Webster mentioned.

Holly Marie Clouse. Photograph courtesy of FHD Forensics

 ‘… simply walked proper out of the bible’

It is been 42 years since Holly was once dropped off by way of a nomadic cult at a church in Arizona and there’s been communicate that this life-changing match took place in Yuma.

Yvonne Peach owns the ancient Coronado Motor Lodge in Yuma and remembers seeing this crew of other people. From the resort’s foyer, she’s noticed an international of other people.

“I might watch other people coming and going, and someday there was once this crew of people who come by way of, they usually more or less stuck my eye as a result of I felt like that they had simply walked proper out of the bible,” Peach mentioned.

She’s been operating on the resort seven days per week since 1979 when she met the landlord John who she later married.

“Yeah that’s them. I consider like, I mentioned, you don’t see other people like that typically, you understand?” Peach mentioned whilst having a look at a photograph of a gaggle of other people wearing all white. “I consider seeing them more than one occasions. It wasn’t simply as soon as. I noticed them a number of occasions.”

The photograph she was once having a look at was once taken many years in the past in Santa Fe, New Mexico by way of Joe Szimhart.

Szimhart spoke with FOX 10 in regards to the non secular crew.

“I used to be a portrait artist in Santa Fe, New Mexico and starting my analysis at the cult phenomenon as a result of I in point of fact simply emerged from a big new age cult myself and loads of other teams, religions, preachers, would display up at the Santa Fe plaza throughout the summer season, whilst I paintings there, and I might meet with them and communicate to them,” Szimhart mentioned.

He is a cult data specialist and he says he’s positive this crew is named the “Christ Circle of relatives.”

Rick Alan Ross, writer of “Cults Inside of Out consents.

“Christ Circle of relatives is among the maximum excessive cults that got here out of the 70s and 80s. It was once led by way of this guy Charles McHugh who was once referred to as ‘Lightning Amen.’ He claimed to be the reincarnation of Jesus Christ, and lots of the participants would suppose the identify Christ as their new remaining identify,” Ross mentioned.

How an Arizona pastor followed an toddler left by way of nomadic ‘cult’ after oldsters’ murders

‘Christ Circle of relatives’ cult. Photograph by way of Joseph Szimhart

Who’s ‘Lightning Amen?’

Who was once this chief?

Mugshots of Amen from California’s Division of Corrections display a middle-aged guy with a definite beard.

“McHugh was once a harsh chief, very excessive. He would manipulate scriptures out of context within the bible to give an explanation for why he must have keep an eye on and gear over his fans’ lives. He additionally was once enthusiastic about unlawful drug trafficking methamphetamine and the gang grew marijuana,” Ross mentioned.

Szimhart provides, “He was once thought to be to be pathological by way of ex-members, you understand, so it wasn’t like brainwashing works endlessly for some other people. It will paintings for a couple of months for some other people, for 10 years, you do not know. It is determined by the individual.”

In 1987, Amen was once sentenced to serve 5 years in jail after being convicted of possessing and transporting meth on the market. In 2001, Amen was once arrested once more, this time accused of 3 counts of exasperating or molesting a kid below 18 – he was once discovered accountable on one rely.

Amen died in 2010. He was once 73.


‘Christ Circle of relatives’ cult

But even so giving up worldly possessions and being vegetarians, participants smoked marijuana as a “sacred herb” and kids weren’t sought after within the crew.

“The glance was once to appear to be nuns and priests and that is the reason why youngsters weren’t essentially a part of the motion,” Szimhart mentioned.

The gang traveled all the way through the southwest areas of america and had been noticed in Yuma again and again within the Eighties.

Why precisely was once this crew nomadic?

“Contributors of Christ Circle of relatives would wander round fundraising … Texas, New Mexico, California, Arizona. They might name this ‘within the wind.’ They might be within the wind, and they might panhandle, they would hustle meals stamps,” Ross mentioned.

So, why would 21-year-old Dean and 17-year-old Tina get entangled with a nomadic non secular crew?

“My trust is that the Clouses made up our minds that they did not need to proceed with the gang. They are going to have additionally witnessed unlawful actions involving the gang’s drug trafficking, so at that time, they disappeared, however they had been murdered, and I do not believe there may be any technique to separate the ones murders from Christ Circle of relatives,” Ross speculated.

Holly’s oldsters nonetheless would not have justice

Family members say they’re in fact relieved that Holly was once by no means harmed.

FOX 10 showed that she was once delivered to a Yuma church someday after her oldsters had been killed and {that a} pastor and his spouse followed Holly, replacing her existence endlessly.

“They had been speaking about adopting, then hastily this child’s dropped on their entrance doorstep almost,” mentioned Debbie Brooks, Holly’s aunt.

On Dean’s birthday this 12 months, June 7, Holly was once discovered and formally recognized. She’s a 42-year-old mom of 5 residing in Oklahoma.

“I do know that God positioned her there, I do know he did. We prayed and prayed …,” Casasanta mentioned. “We are simply so thankful that this circle of relatives did get very, very thankful,” Brooks added.

Holly’s organic oldsters nonetheless don’t have justice, and in spite of the cult being defunct for many years, investigators know somebody has data.

“What we wish to know is who, and why, why, you understand? What was once your reasoning at the back of killing them?” Brooks mentioned.

You need to observe that Holly’s adoptive oldsters have by no means been suspects on this case.

The “Dean and Tina Linn Clouse Memorial Fund” now helps legislation enforcement genetic family tree investigations. The function is to assist establish John and Jane Does with households looking ahead to solutions.

Somebody who has guidelines in this case can e-mail [email protected].

Genie Mathena

Learn More →